Top Real Estate Agents in Key West, FL – December 2025
Find the best real estate agents in Key West, FL. See who's closing the most deals, selling fastest, and dominating the market—backed by 12 months of MLS data.
We analyzed 684 MLS transactions across 214 agents in Key West over the last 12 months to find who's actually moving property. Here's what the data says.
Key Market Stats
- Median Home Price: $1.2M
- Avg Days on Market: 98 days
- #1 Agent: Brenda Donnelly (23 transactions, $53.3M volume)
Key West Housing Market Snapshot
Understanding the current market conditions helps you set realistic expectations and negotiate effectively.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Median Home Price | $1.2M |
| Avg Days on Market | 98 days |
| Listings Selling Under 30 Days | 18% |
| Listings on Market 90+ Days | 41% |
| Price Trend (vs Prior Quarter) | +4.2% |
Buyer's Market
How to Choose the Right Real Estate Agent in Key West
Finding the right agent is about more than just transaction volume. Here's what to look for:
Ask these before signing with any Key West agent:
- How many homes have you sold in Key West in the past 12 months?
- How often will you update me, and through what channels?
- How do you determine list price? What's your sale-to-list ratio?
- What specific tactics will you use to market my property?
- Can you provide contact info for 3 recent clients?
Walk away if you see these warning signs:
- No recent local deals — They may not know the current market.
- Vague marketing — "We'll put it on the MLS" isn't a strategy.
- Pressure tactics — Good agents educate, not push.
Which structure fits your needs?
| Team | Solo Agent | |
|---|---|---|
| Availability | More coverage | Single point of contact |
| Specialization | Dedicated roles | Generalist approach |
| Communication | May vary by team member | Consistent relationship |
| Best for | High-volume, fast markets | Personalized attention |
Key West Agent Rankings
| Rank | Agent | Brokerage | Transactions | Total Volume | Cohort |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brenda Donnelly | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate LLC - Broker | 23 | $53.3M | Top 5% |
| 2 | Suzanne Moore | Suzanne Moore Real Estate | 23 | $46.4M | Top 5% |
| 3 | Bobby Coe | — | 22 | $46.8M | Top 5% |
| 4 | Bascom Grooms Iv | Bascom Grooms Real Estate - Broker | 21 | $24.0M | Top 5% |
| 5 | Terri Spottswood | Truman Co. Broker | 13 | $33.0M | Top 10% |
| 6 | Jimmy Lane | Island Life Realty Experts - Broker | 13 | $12.0M | Top 10% |
| 7 | Michael Behmke | Keller Williams Key West Compass Realty - Broker | 13 | $24.9M | Top 10% |
| 8 | J. Michael Caron | Keller Williams Key West Compass Realty - Broker | 10 | $14.8M | Top 10% |
| 9 | Teamkaufelt | Truman Co. Broker | 10 | $25.7M | Top 10% |
| 10 | Sean Farrer | Coldwell Banker Schmitt - Broker | 9 | $6.1M | Top 25% |
Rankings based on MLS transaction data. Cohort percentile calculated against all agents in the market.
Top Agents by Transaction Volume
Speed to Sale: Agent vs Market Average
Agents highlighted in orange sell faster than the Key West market average of 98 days.
Total Sales Volume
Need an Agent in Key West?
Get Matched with a Top Agent
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll connect you with a top-performing agent in your area.
Methodology
Data Collection
We analyzed 684 MLS listings in Key West, FL from the last 12 months, sourced from our proprietary database of 21M+ nationwide transactions.
Ranking Calculation
Agents are ranked by transaction count with a minimum of 3 transactions required. Cohort percentiles compare each agent against all agents in the market.
Performance Metrics
We calculate days on market, total volume, and average sale price to provide a complete performance picture.
Frequently Asked Questions
How We Keep This List Updated
This ranking of top real estate agents in Key West is updated monthly using the latest MLS transaction data. Our automated pipeline processes millions of records to identify agents with consistent, verifiable performance.
What triggers ranking changes:
- New transactions closing in the MLS
- Shifts in agent volume relative to market peers
- Updated brokerage affiliations
Last updated: 12-30-2025
About This Data
Rankings are based solely on MLS transaction data. Tab Tab Labs does not accept payment for placement. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Always interview multiple agents before making a decision.
Ready to Dominate Your Market?
We help real estate investors and agent teams find more deals with AI-powered lead generation, automated follow-up, and custom CRM systems.